Welcome

Anti Essays offers essay examples to help students with their essay writing.

Sign Up

Trust Votes in Technicolour Essay

Open Document

Below is an essay on "Trust Votes in Technicolour" from Anti Essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples.

India's first Trust Vote in the age of 24 hour news television transformed parliamentary debate into a reality show. The politicians were the star performers while the nation played judge and audience. The drama in parliament was hilarious and tragic by turn. Lakhs of rupees were suddenly unveiled and scattered on the speaker's table inside the Lok Sabha. The voting technology failed to rise to the occasion. Some members of parliament were wheeled into the house on stretchers. Lalu Prasad Yadav had the House in splits when he confessed his not-so secret desire to be prime minister. Yet a single question remained: is parliamentary democracy being strengthened by what we have observed this week?

Take the case of the convicted MPs who were given a week off from their prison cells to come and vote. While there is seemingly no legal bar on a convicted member of parliament voting, there are ethical questions which must be raised when those convicted of crimes like murder can decide the destiny of parliament. In a trust vote where every vote counts, political parties may claim they have every right to rope in their Shahabuddins and Pappu Yadavs. After all, whether we like it or not, they are elected by the people. But just as the law does not bar them from entering parliament, is there a rule that makes it mandatory for them to be present during a confidence vote? A government can be defeated in parliament during a finance bill, does that mean that every time a finance bill is being put to vote, our convicted MPs should get a break from jail?

Indeed, the law versus morality question has now become central to parliamentary practices. Legally, the government won the confidence vote, but is there a moral content to our politics that must rise above the law? Ten members abstained from the trust vote, another half a dozen cross voted. How many of these were conscientious objectors to their party line, and how many were simply switching sides because of the monetary...

Show More


Citations

MLA Citation

"Trust Votes in Technicolour". Anti Essays. 10 Dec. 2018

<http://cassandralynndesignllc.com/free-essays/Trust-Votes-Technicolour-238005.html>

APA Citation

Trust Votes in Technicolour. Anti Essays. Retrieved December 10, 2018, from the World Wide Web: http://cassandralynndesignllc.com/free-essays/Trust-Votes-Technicolour-238005.html